[Attributes by Finsweet] CMS Filter

Success Stories

Verdicts & Appeals

select an attorney

Davis v. OB/GYN

Gregory A. Crisman

Claim:

Whether the defendant negligently sutured right ureter during total abdominal hysterectomy procedure.

Outcome:

Directed verdict for defendant.

Brian Swickard v. Defendant General Surgeon

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant negligently caused retained sponge during emergency surgical repair of abdominal gunshot wound injuries.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Emma Davis v. Estate of E.R. Physician

Kirk D. Bagrowski

Claim:

Plaintiff alleged that defendant physician negligently treated her in the emergency room, and failed to diagnose and admit her to the hospital.

Outcome:

Directed verdict for E.R. Physician.

Truck City of Gary v. National Industrial Lumber Co., et al.

Kirk D. Bagrowski

Claim:

Plaintiff alleged that defendant breached contract for repair of trucks.

Outcome:

Plaintiff verdict.

Estate of Carolyn Davis, deceased v. Defendant Emergency Physician, et al.

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant failed to appreciate severity of patient’ s illness and co-morbidities in failing to hospitalize her, resulting in her death on third day after release from emergency room.

Outcome:

Directed verdict for Defendant Emergency Physician. (Verdict for plaintiff as to co-defendant).

Mary Steenbergen v. Defendant Plastic Surgeon

Michael Roth

Claim:

Plaintiff alleged that defendant physician failed to properly replace Silicone implants.

Outcome:

Dismissal with prejudice on eve of trial.

Brent Worley v. Volkswagen of America, Inc. d/b/a Audi of America

Robert J. Feldt

Claim:

Product defect/warranty claim involving an Audi A4.

Outcome:

Judgment on the evidence for Audi in a jury trial.

Timothy Wotherspoon v. Northern Indiana Public Service Company and NiSource, Inc., et al.

Robert J. Feldt

Claim:

Loading dock accident/crush injury to leg.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Low v. Orthopedic Surgeon

Gregory A. Crisman

Claim:

Whether the defendant negligently performed left foot plantar fascia release and heel spur excision surgery, causing complete disability.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Dixie Click-Smith v. Defendant General Surgeon

Michael Roth

Claim:

Plaintiff alleged that defendant physician failed to properly emergent laparotomy.

Outcome:

Defense dismissal.

David Lee Sedden v. Defendant Family Practitioner

Michael Roth

Claim:

Plaintiff alleged that defendant physician failed to properly diagnose, treat, and follow-up for cellulitus on lower extremities, subsequently led to necrotizing infection requiring over 20 additional surgeries.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Tracy Ryan v. Defendant Attorney

David C. Jensen

Claim:

Whether defendant attorney was negligent in accepting settlement in underlying sexual harassment case.

Outcome:

Mr. Jensen tried the case for the defendant lawyer. There was a defense verdict.

Estate of Mary Owens v. Defendant– Internist

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether defendant unnecessarily and/or negligently performed liver biopsy.

Outcome:

Plaintiff verdict.

Awad Abdulqader v. Defendant Utility

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant negligently placed utility pole adjacent to curve in road resulting in severe bodily injury when plaintiff’ s car left roadway. (Jury Demand $1.5 Million)

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Nauracy v. OB/GYN

John M. McCrum

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Alleged wrongful maternal death in delivery resulting from failure to properly treat intrapartum infection.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Cindy Stantz v. Estate of Defendant Internist

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant was negligent in his diagnosis and treatment of depression and sinusitis, causing addiction, and complications from corticosteroid use.

Outcome:

Verdict for Plaintiff, $344,474.

Dona Leigh Sparks, guardian of Rose Dusza v. Defendant Anesthesia/Pain Management Physician, et al

Gregory A. Crisman

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether pain management specialist failed to timely diagnose infection and administer appropriate antibiotics to 58 year old woman with dehisced morphine pump, causing meningitis and severe brain injury. (Final jury demand: $3.8 Million)

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Raymond Nield, Indiv. and as Admin. of Est. of Barbara A. Nield, Deceased v. Defendants - Orthopedic Surgeons

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether decedent died of an MI following hip replacement surgery and whether the standard of care required defendant to request cardiac clearance before surgery.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

LaBorde v. OB/GYN

John M. McCrum

Claim:

Alleged negligent performance of laparoscopic hysterectomy resulting in injury to bowel and bladder and claimed permanent damages.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Westchester Fire Ins. Co. v. American Wood Fibers, Inc.

John P. Twohy

Claim:

Insurer claimed that defendant’s product caused $20 million casualty loss to insured’s factory.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Dale & Marjorie Guibert v. Defendant General Surgeon

Alyssa Stamatakos

Claim:

Whether defendant negligently performed surgery, causing lengthy hospitalization.

Outcome:

Final demand: $75,001. Final offer: $0. Defense verdict.

Ana Jimenez v. Defendant Dentist

John P. Twohy

Claim:

Plaintiff claimed injury from defendant dentist’s removal of impression tray from mouth.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Estate of Micaela Rodriguez, et al v. Defendant Physician, Defendant Gastroenterologist, Defendant Family Physician, Defendant Nephrologist, et al

David C. Jensen

Claim:

Whether the defendants breached the standard of care in their treatment of plaintiff’s decedent, Micaela Rodriguez.

Outcome:

Mr. Jensen tried the case. There was a Defense Verdict

Mary & Richard Fafara v. Defendant OB/GYN, et al

Alyssa Stamatakos

Claim:

Whether defendant was negligent in the delivery of baby who had permanent Erb’s palsy.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Gloria Stapleton and Martin Stapleton v. Defendant - Radiologist et al.

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether defendant negligently failed to diagnose hip fracture on x-ray.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Text on a wall reading "Eichhorn & Eichhorn Attorneys at Law" in large, grey, capital letters.

Let Us Know How We Can Serve You