[Attributes by Finsweet] CMS Filter

Success Stories

Verdicts & Appeals

select an attorney

Dorothy Ward, as guardian of Roger Roundtree v. Defendant - Primary Care

David C. Jensen

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether amputation of lower extremity could have been prevented by timely treatment of peripheral vascular disease.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Brenda Moody, et al v. Emergency Department Physician

John M. McCrum

Robert J. Feldt

Claim:

Wrongful death action, alleged mismanagement of fulminant infection.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Rocco Fridono v. Defendant Neurosurgeon

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant’ s performance of posterior cervical laminectomy was without sufficient indications.

Outcome:

Defense verdict, affirmed on appeal.

Perrin v. General Surgeon

David C. Jensen

Gregory A. Crisman

Claim:

Whether defendant adequately informed plaintiff of risks of umbilical hernia surgery and properly managed her postoperative care; subsequent development of sepsis necessitating three month hospitalization and amputation of toes bilaterally.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Lloyd and Gloria Atwell v. Defendant Gastroenterologist

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether gastroenterologist had sufficient indication to perform endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, which was complicated by postop pancreatitis.

Outcome:

Verdict for plaintiff: $605,000.

Ayala v. Family Practitioner

John M. McCrum

Claim:

Alleged mismanagement of diabetes resulting in permanent complications.

Outcome:

Plaintiffs' verdict.

Hughes v. Family Practice Physician

Gregory A. Crisman

Claim:

Alleged failure to properly treat fracture-dislocation of elbow in eleven year old male patient; medical review panel found against defendant on both standard of care and causation.

Outcome:

Final Demand: $750,000. Final Offer: $0. Verdict for Plaintiff: $250,000.

Dancyzk v. Cardiologist and Cardiothoracic Surgeon

John M. McCrum

Claim:

Alleged delay in diagnosis and treatment of heart attack resulting in permanent heart damage.

Outcome:

Plaintiffs' verdict.

Judith Murzyn v. Defendant Orthopedic Surgeon

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether the defendant orthopedic surgeon negligently failed to timely diagnose distal radial fracture.

Outcome:

Verdict for plaintiff: $85,000.

Harco, Inc. Paving Co. v. Plainfield Interstate Dining

Michael Roth

Claim:

Business dispute over foreclosure of mechanics lien related to paving subcontractor who performed work on new construction of a Burger King franchise.

Outcome:

Defense Verdict for client and $60,000 judgment on counterclaim. Upheld on Appeal.

Pamela Martin v. Jack Martin and Old Farm, Inc.

Michael Roth

Claim:

Business and family dispute over former spouse’s share of family business more than 10 years following final divorce decree.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Bailey v. NIPSCO

Alyssa Stamatakos

Claim:

Wrongful death action against NIPSCO resulting from one of its drivers running over and killing the plaintiff’s decedent with his truck.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Rae v. Plastic Surgeon

Gregory A. Crisman

Claim:

Whether or not the defendant negligently left retained foreign body after septoplasty procedure.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Janet Riney (Carrie Brewster) v. Defendant - Orthopedic Surgeon

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether defendant negligently set wrist fracture of 14 year old which caused nerve damage and required surgical realignment.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Lucretia Little, John Davis and John L. Davis v. Defendant OB/GYN

David C. Jensen

Claim:

Whether defendant obstetrician was negligent in rendering prenatal care.

Outcome:

Defense verdict

Tim Pickett, Plaintiff/Counter-Defendant and NIPSCO Security Services, Inc. v. Dorothy Hurley

Robert J. Feldt

Claim:

Motor vehicle accident

Outcome:

Small verdict for Defendant as Cross-Plaintiff.

Larry D. Hakes, Jr. and Susan Hakes v. Defendant - Orthopedic Surgeon

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether the defendant removed excessive bone and cartilage from ankle joint, which led to subsequent ankle fusion.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Carol Reich v. Defendant - Orthopedic Surgeon

David J. Beach

Claim:

Whether defendant negligently treated foot abscess in patient who had her leg amputated four days later.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Karla Smith v. Defendant Orthopedic Surgeon

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant failed to diagnose tibial fracture non-union or prematurely removed internal fixation plate.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Wilson v. City of East Chicago

James L. Hough

Claim:

Represented plaintiff in claim for failure to take reasonable care to prevent suicide of detainee.

Outcome:

Plaintiff Verdict for $400,000.

Marc & Bridget Hertzberg v. Defendant OB/GYN

Alyssa Stamatakos

Claim:

Whether defendant failed to diagnose breast cancer in 28-year old patient.

Outcome:

Final demand: $750,000. Final Offer: 0. Hung jury. Case later settled for $35,000.

Boyd v. Neurosurgeon

John M. McCrum

Claim:

Alleged malpractice in performance of multiple lumbar spine surgeries resulting in claimed permanent impairment.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Hugo Garcia v. Defendant Orthopedic Surgeon

Louis W. Voelker, III

Claim:

Whether defendant failed to timely diagnose non-union of a femoral condyle fracture. (Final Demand: $750, 000, Final Offer: $20,000)

Outcome:

Verdict for plaintiff: $11,000.

Daniel Santana v. Defendant OB/GYN

John P. Twohy

Claim:

Plaintiffs alleged that minor child sustained injury in utero from administration of ACE inhibitor to mother for treatment of hypertension during pregnancy.

Outcome:

Defense verdict.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Text on a wall reading "Eichhorn & Eichhorn Attorneys at Law" in large, grey, capital letters.

Let Us Know How We Can Serve You